MIDI vs MusicXML: What's the Difference and Which Should You Use?

MIDI records a performance, MusicXML describes a written score. Here's what that means for playback, notation and practice.

MIDI: a recording of a performance

MIDI (Musical Instrument Digital Interface), standardized in 1983, stores performance events: which key went down, when, how hard, and when it was released, plus controller data such as the sustain pedal. It contains no sound — a synthesizer or sampler turns the events into audio — and it does not store how the music should be written: no clefs, beams, stems, or spelling of sharps versus flats.

Because MIDI captures real timing, it is perfect for recording what someone actually played on a digital piano, and for falling-note playback, which follows real time.

MusicXML: a description of a written score

MusicXML, introduced in 2004 and now maintained by the W3C Music Notation Community Group, describes notation: measures, clefs, key and time signatures, note values, voices, slurs, dynamics, lyrics and layout. Almost every notation program (MuseScore, Finale, Sibelius, Dorico) can import and export it.

MusicXML is the right choice when you want to read, print or edit sheet music, or see a highlighted score while the music plays.

Converting between them

Turning MusicXML into MIDI is easy and exact, because a score fully defines its notes. Turning MIDI into MusicXML is harder: the software must guess the beat, quantize human timing, split notes between hands and decide how to spell each note. Results from a strict, quantized MIDI file are good; results from a live performance usually need some cleanup.

Piano: Soloist opens both: MIDI files are converted to notation automatically so you can see a score alongside the falling notes.

Which to use

Use MusicXML when a written score exists and accuracy of notation matters. Use MIDI when you have a recording from a keyboard or a file from a game or app. If you only have a PDF or an audio recording, convert it first — PDF through optical music recognition, audio through automatic transcription.

Related

More guides